|
What
type of business?
Before
looking ahead we would suggest that perhaps a look back might be worthwhile.
As most people buying small businesses are mature persons with work
histories behind them they need to, initially perhaps, decide what businesses
they would not be best suited to. Although self-confidence is an attribute
in any business enterprise it matters more in a shop selling computers
- where good communication and Sales skills are essential - than it
does in a Chip Shop where the quality of the chips is what brings the
customers in the second time.
Having
decided what you definitely don't want to do, be assured there is a
lot to choose from - and don't be too narrow in your view of what might
be the right business for you.
Profitability and price
As
it's all - or primarily - about making money it wouldn't be a bad idea
to make yourself aware of the profit margins applying in various businesses.
The initial indicator is the Gross Profit - the profit as a percentage
of the selling price (more of which later). A newsagent will have a
gross profit between 18/20%, a cafe 55/60% and that Fish & Chip shop?
- well the accounts will (almost without exception) show 55% as to declare
less would be to invite an investigation by the Inland Revenue, it is
likely, however that most chip shops will have a genuine GP perhaps
nearer to 70% - an interesting supposition bringing us to the question
of how to determine whether the price being asked is reasonable.
What do the accounts say?
All
businesses are required, by law, to produce formal accounts and the
job is normally given to one of the 100's of chartered accountants to
be round in Yellow Pages, although it is permissible for a proprietor,
with the necessary skill, to produce the accounts in-house.
The
accounts for most small businesses (sole traders or partnerships) are
compiled wholly from detail supplied by the trader, the accountant's
job being no more than to collate and present in the prescribed manner
- and to be sufficiently aware of relevant tax legislation to minimise
the tax payable on the net profit t is therefore worthwhile remembering
that the primary objective of the accountant is to minimise tax liability
- not demonstrate optimum profitability.
It
is possible therefore that the accounts may not show the true worth
of the business so the prospective purchaser needs a little guidance
to sensibly interpret the "£4,000 p.w. @ 20% G.P." which is often the
only financial data given in the sale particulars of a business for
sale. The first points to check are: is the £4,000 per week, the vendor
says the business is doing, an accounts stated annual figure divided
by 52?; is it including or net of VAT? (it appears to be standard practice
for Business Agents to quote "takings" i.e. including VAT in press advertising
- but sale particulars should state 'net of' or 'including VAT').
Be
aware that the agent may be instructed to publicise a figure of weekly
sales for annual turnover) that the accounts will not substantiate;
the advertisement or the sale particulars detail should give an indication
in this regard. Be tuned in to 'agent speak' e.g. "the vendor advises
of takings being..." or "the declared takings are" or perhaps "the accounts
may not reflect the true value (takings) of the business". It could
also be that the takings are actually less - so beware.
You
may be convinced that the business is taking more than the accounts
suggest, and perhaps the tax man is lenient to a degree, but the bank
manager will not be persuaded and the ability of the business to support
a loan will be judged only on the figures given in the published accounts.
Only
the vendor can convince of the true level of takings, and whilst the
prospective purchaser may be convinced of higher-than-accounted sales
(a strong incentive to paying a good price), it is not a good enough
reason to pay 'over the odds'.
What are you actually buying?
What
you will be asked to pay for is the "Goodwill", the Fixtures & Fittings/Equipment
and the Property (or in the case of a Leasehold - the "Leasehold Interest").
Little explanation is required with regard to the value of the Fixtures
& Fittings - the true value being what it would cost to replace with
the same items in the age and condition they are in. The property valve
may well determine the amount you can borrow and will depend upon the
value the lending source's valuer puts on it. But what about Goodwill
- indeed, what is Goodwill!
The
simplest definition is to see Goodwill as "the value put on the established
trade" be this due to a good reputation of long standing or the fact
that the owner has taken a financial risk in setting up the business,
or that it is in the ideal trading location (positioning to within a
few metres can be critical). It can be a mixture of such elements and
can also be a reflection of the popularity of a business in terms of
a prospective purchaser's view of their ability to effectively manage
it e.g. many feel they can take on a Newsagency and do a good job but
one can't imagine anyone without trade experience taking on a Butcher's
or a Hairdresser's, so - £ for £ of operating net profit the Goodwill
in a Newsagent is valued at significantly more than for 'skill necessitating'
businesses. Then there are sub Post 0ffices where the Goodwill is highly
rated because the business is seen as captive/secure (which is more
or less the case). Do expect to pay a substantial premium for the Goodwill
in a sub Post Office.
It
must of course, make sense to build Goodwill rather than buy it but
that is very much easier said than done, it's all about resources and
risk i.e. any bank will take a lot of persuading to back a brand new
small business venture and even if there is no need of borrowing there
is no guarantee the business will succeed, so Goodwill established is
an intrinsic part of any profitable business.
Theoretically,
the ideal business is one which has a niche in the market; i.e. it commands
the attention of buyers who can afford to purchase its wares at a price
that returns a good profit. It is also a business the big operators,
supermarkets, department stores, DIY multiples etc. either can't be
bothered with at all or don't wish to offer the range of product available
from a niche market specialist. There is definitely a case for looking
at the business you hadn't thought of, does it have a good level of
operating net profit? - and an accounts history to show it is not a
'flash in the pan'? if so then perhaps it's worth serious consideration.
Freehold or leasehold?
When
a business is offered 'Freehold' it means it operates from premises
owned by the vendor - i.e. the sale price including the property as
described.
Prospective
business buyers, particularly first timers, often deny themselves the
opportunity of acquiring a good business because they feel they really
should own the property. This is an understandable attitude given the
emphasis put on the so-called Property Owning Democracy in recent years
where it is thought wrong/wasteful to rent/lease. This is perhaps a
supportable viewpoint as regards housing one's family, but in considering
the 'housing' of a business, a preoccupation with owning the property
can be counter-productive, and even dangerous if, as many have found
to their cost in the late 80's, one has placed more faith in the 'bricks'
than on the business!
There
are too many, instances where business buyers have placed too much emphasis
on the bricks & mortar and not enough on the capability of the business
to pay for them and - after running expenses & loan repayments - leave
enough to support a standard of living it is reasonable for them to
expect.
It
is vital to consider what the business can afford to support in terms
of living accommodation if one is determined to live over the shop.
There are vital questions you should be asking yourself: e.g. "is it
really necessary to buy the building to get at the business I want?"
and "do I really want to live over the shop, why don't I keep my house
and use it as security to buy the business and (if applicable) let the
living accommodation?" To address sensibly these questions it is necessary
to have some knowledge of Leaseholding; but before considering this
here are a few points to bear in mind.
The
better the trading position the more expensive the 'bricks' will be.
So expensive, that perhaps you should consider doing what most of the
high street retail multiples do i.e. rent/lease the premises.
The
rent you might charge for any living accommodation over the shop could
pay a significant pat of the rent overall, making the profit projections
a little more attractive.
Here
are a few points which should dispel some fears related to taking on
a lease.
- You
only buy it once! Seeing businesses advertised for sale 'Leasehold'
and then noting that the Lease has, say, 10 years of the current term
remaining may prompt the conclusion that the Leasehold has to be purchased
again when the current term ends and you wish to continue as the tenant.
This is not so.
- The
Landlord cannot simply tell you to leave at the end of the term. Tenants
do have the protection of law - namely, the Landlord & Tenant Act,
wherein are laid out the circumstances under which a Landlord may
seek 'reversion' of the property; these are:
- You
are a bad tenant i.e. you don't comply with the basic terms of
the Lease; e.g. you have been consistently in arrears with the
rent, or have failed to maintain the property as set out.
- The
Landlord wishes to reoccupy the premises for his own personal
use or that of a member of his immediate family.
- The
premises are, perhaps, part of a parade which is to be totally
redeveloped and you are the only tenant who has not agreed terms
for reversion.
There
may be other (exceptional) grounds for reversion, which is why you will
need to take the advice of a solicitor before getting in too deep, but
even in the exceptional instances where a Landlord does seek reversion
he has to do so in compliance within The Act, there is compensation
[ (a) excepted ] - and it takes time.
In
most instances therefore the Landlord is only too keen to grant a new
term as his income depends on someone (preferably the existing tenant)
taking on the new term, the last thing a Landlord wants is to have the
premises standing empty, even for a short time, as then it costs, rather
than earns, money.
If
a new Lease is offered there may be a prospect of negotiation regarding
the number of years the Lease will run (before the next renewal) and,
of course, the rent. As regards the term; simply put one might say that
generally the Landlord would prefer the term to be as long as possible,
let's say 25 years, because this commits the tenant to paying a rent
over that period of (if he decides to move out) of finding a suitable
replacement tenant to whom the lease can be 're-assigned', (this element
is the basic difference between Leasing and Renting i.e. the commitment
of each party to the Lease is more long term - to mutual benefit - as
opposed to simply renting where an agreed notice of intention to terminate
may be all that is required to sever the connection).
Commercial
rents are normally paid 3 months in advance and are subject to review
(in line with market conditions prevailing) at 3 or 5 yearly intervals
throughout the term.
Knowing
that the Landlord will, more likely than not, have no option other than
to grant a new term when that current expires, the prospective tenant
may be more pre occupied with securing a loan. The proposed lender will,
however, also be interested in the number of years the term has to run
as, for obvious reasons, no lender would wish to lend over a longer
period than the occupancy of the premises from which it operated was
assured. Where the term of the existing lease has less years (to renewal)
than the number over which you had hoped to borrow then you will not
find a lender. In such circumstances the Landlord will generally agree
to giant an extension or even a new lease, whereupon, you might find
yourself borrowing over 6 years of a 10 year, or 10 of a 15 year term.
The Landlord may, of course, seek a benefit for being so cooperative
by attempting to negotiate other elements to his greater advantage.
Then it is up to you, with the guidance of a solicitor, to decide whether
or not to accept. You would have to pay the costs in establishing a
new Lease or, in the normal transfer of ownership of a business, the
Landlord's solicitor's costs in re-assigning the existing Lease to you.
It
is not uncommon, particularly when new businesses are being established,
for the Landlord to offer (or the prospective Tenant to negotiate) a
'break? term whereby, at the end of the first year of a 5 year term,
say, the tenant might walk away without having to find a replacement.
Such 'breaks' can also be at the end of the first 5 years of, say, a
15 year term; most advantageous in a situation where a business has
perhaps been so successful it has outgrown the original premises but
was constrained in moving/developing further by the commitment of having
to re-assign the existing lease.
Borrowing limits
lf
you are thinking of buying a business it is important that you are realistic
in setting your financial limits. This means knowing how much you can
borrow and whether you will be able to meet the repayments; this section
gives basic information and examples.
Freehold
You
can normally borrow up to 70% of the purchase price or occasionally
75%, but with two main conditions:
- The
loan must not exceed the bricks-and-mortar value; the total purchase
price being made up of three parts: property/bricks and mortar, fixtures
and fittings, and goodwill.
- There
must be sufficient net profit available, after paying the fixed costs,
to meet the loan repayments and see enough left over for family living
expenses.
Leasehold
You
can normally borrow up to 50 - 60% of the purchase price if the business
has living accommodation. If it is a lock-up the limit may be lower,
depending on your financial status.
Again there are two main conditions:
- There
must be sufficient operating net profit available to meet repayments
and allow for a comfortable standard of living.
- It
is essential to bear in mind that it is not possible to borrow unsecured
when purchasing a leasehold business i.e, the purchaser may have 50%
of the purchase price but to borrow the other 50% the loan has to
be 'secured' by a tangible asset of at least equivalent value. This
security may be a freehold property which is not fully mortgaged or
a surety by an individual prepared to act as your guarantor. A potential
lender will also take account of any additional income available to
support the loan e.g. if, say, a wife wanted to buy a teashop to run
with her mother the husband's salary could be taken into account.
Endowment insurance policies and other such investments can be acceptable
sources of loan security.
Valuations:
Requirements
vary between lenders, but all loans are normally subject to the lender's
assessment of business viability. An independent business survey/valuation
may be demanded and/or a bricks-and-mortar valuation in respect of a
freehold purchase.
Repayments
Freehold
Businesses:
Loans
are most commonly over 15 years and interest rates 3-5% above the prevailing
Bank of England base rate.
Leasehold
Businesses:
Loans
are usually over 5, 7, 10 or 15 years and the interest rates are normally
3 or 3.5%, but can be as much as 5 or (exceptionally) 7% above base
rate. The loan period can be varied and is negotiable, the interest
rate charged will vary depending on the type of business, your financial
status and the lending source criteria current at the time of loan application.
It is always wise to shop around, starting with your own bank and perhaps
the vendors bank - they should know how sound a business it is. You
might then speak to the selling agent who will be able to advise of
the likely best alternative source.
To
Work 0ut Repayments:
The
table given is for guidance only. It shows the monthly repayment per
£1,000 borrowed over a particular term. The figures are based on even
spread repayments covering capital and interest.
| Interest |
Term
of loan (years) |
| rate
(%) |
5 |
7 |
10 |
15 |
|
£ |
£ |
£ |
£ |
| 8 |
20.25 |
15.56 |
12.11 |
9.53 |
| 8.5 |
20.49 |
15.80 |
12.36 |
9.81 |
| 9 |
20.72 |
16.06 |
12.63 |
10.10 |
| 9.5 |
20.96 |
16.30 |
12.90 |
10.40 |
| 10 |
21.21 |
16.56 |
13.17 |
10.69 |
| 10.5 |
21.45 |
16.81 |
13.44 |
11.00 |
| 11 |
21.73 |
17.12 |
13.77 |
11.25 |
| 11.5 |
21.99 |
17.39 |
14.07 |
11.59 |
| 12 |
22.24 |
17.65 |
14.35 |
12.00 |
| 12.5 |
22.50 |
17.92 |
14.64 |
12.33 |
| 13 |
22.75 |
18.19 |
14.93 |
12.65 |
| 13.5 |
23.01 |
18.46 |
15.23 |
12.98 |
| 14 |
23.27 |
18.74 |
15.53 |
13.32 |
| 14.5 |
23.53 |
19.02 |
15.83 |
13.66 |
| 15 |
23.79 |
19.30 |
16.13 |
14.00 |
|
How much do I need to borrow?
A
simple enough calculation, but one where mistakes are often made. You
must remember to allow for stock and miscellaneous costs such as legal
fees. Add these to the agreed purchase price and deduct your available
capital - and if this is coming from a property sale remember to allow
for mortgage repayment plus estate agent's and legal fees.
Can I afford it?
Work
out your borrowing requirements and then work out the likely repayments.
Next work out the Operating/Available Net Profit of the business based
on the sales and expenses detailed in the profit and loss account. From
the gross profit deduct the essential running costs./overheads as they
would apply to any owner, adding any exceptional costs shown in the
accounts back in to the net profit, e.g. the accounts of a corner shop owner
might show the telephone costs to be very high (when he 'phones his
family he could be talking to the other side of the world) or perhaps
the accounts presented show exceptional repairs and renewals in the
year considered such as spending on a new shop front, making it necessary
to use an average figure. Well constructed business sale particulars
should give a reasoned assessment or 0perating Net Profit (net profit
available after meeting costs common to any operator).
From
this - the most important figure for a potential business buyer to
determine - must be deducted the loan repayments calculated before
the family income can be determined. Do note that in some shops (particularly
in those retailing food and household goods) the family will, to a degree,
live off the business.
Example
Mr.
& Mrs. Smith want to buy a freehold convenience store with living accommodation
at £130,000.
They are selling their own house and will have capital available of
£70,000 after fees.
Their borrowing requirement is:
| Business
price |
£130,000 |
| Stock,
say |
12,000 |
| Misc.
Fees, say |
3,000 |
|
|
|
145,000 |
|
|
| Less
Capital |
(70,000) |
|
|
| Loan
Required |
£75,000 |
|
|
With
£75,000 being less than 70% of the £130,000 and likely to be less
than the bricks- and-mortar value (against which the loan will be secured),
the loan should be possible subject to repayment ability, i.e. if the
shop makes enough profit to comfortably pay off the loan and leave enough
over to sustain an acceptable lifestyle.
If
we assume a base rate of, say, 7% and a 15 year loan at 3% over base
i.e. an interest rate of 10%, referring to the table we see that monthly
repayments before any tax relief will be:
75
x £10.69 - £801.75pcm or £9,621pa
(Let's call this £10,000 in round figures)
The
accounts for the shop show a turnover (net of VAT) of £220,000 p.a.
with a gross profit of £40,000 p.a. It is established that the basic
running costs (after reconstituting/analysing to compensate for current
owner specific and exceptional costs) are £10,000 p.a. before paying
£5,000 in staff wages to part time assistants, so the available/operating
net profit is £25,000. After deducting the £10,000 loan repayments
the Smiths will be left with £15,000 for living expenses. Such a business
would represent a comfortable living as, to a degree, many of the day
on day living expenses will be met out of / by the business.
| Be
aware - do not confuse 'MARK UP' with 'MARGIN'. Gross
profit is the profit as a percentage of the selling price.
i.e. Bought for 10 and sold for 15 is a 50% MARK UP but only
a 33% gross profit MARG1N. Put another way: |
| G.P.%
- |
| ____MARK
UP____ |
| COST
+ MARK UP |
|
X
100 |
Get this wrong and disaster will ensue! |
|
|
Independent,
specialist valuations (e.g. Pindar) can support business proposals where
formal accounting data is unavailable, and will be considered by lending
sources. Although it is a fact that many small business operators do
get seriously behind with their provision of formal accounts they are
not permitted to be late with VAT returns. The 'outputs' figure on the
VAT return is the declared net of VAT quarterly sales figure which (x
4) will give assurance re current and past sales performance per VAT
year. Be realistic in deciding what you can afford and don't be discouraged
if it doesn't seem as if the business can support the loan you need;
difficult cases can become possible with expert handling, especially
if you have plans to improve the business - or the accounts do not give
a true indication of the true profits of the business.
The business plan
Do
try and do your sums before approaching a lender, and put together a
Business Plan. This might seem a daunting task, but it need be no more
than a simple month-on-month projection of sales, hopefully showing
some expected improvement due to your new lines introduced (or unprofitable
lines deleted!), or perhaps a face-lift for the shop - or whatever.
This will be aligned with the projected costs of running the business
under your ownership. It might, for instance, show that in the first
year you will dispense with an element or the hired help and put the
saving into development. The objective (essential to you and not simply
to impress the bank) is to show that you are serious about this business,
that you have carefully. thought it through, intend to be successful
and have a basic plan showing how you see this success being achieved.
You
will need an accountant, and you could well find a company that will
give you some basic business plan assistance free of charge in return
for you giving them your business when you are established - but don't
forget to ask how much it will cost. The cost will vary from one company
to another and will be based on time taken i.e. the better/tidier your
book keeping the lesser the fee. Are you to prepare your own VAT and
income tax returns or have the accountant do them for you? Taking into
account all these variables, annual costs for this essential service
can vary (for sole trader/partnership business such as the example given)
from £400 to £1,000 per financial year.
Lending sources
There
are many sources of business finance, including major banks - some more
attuned to the needs of small businesses than others - and specialist
brokers who can often find a source which will back a business the banks
have turned down Brokers do charge a basic nominal fee but their commission
is paid by the lending source.
All
possible lenders will require specific detail regarding yourself (and
your partner) with respect to personal, job history and financial standing.
Considering buying a sub-post office?
Strictly
speaking, one cannot "buy" a sub post office, rather one is "appointed
to the position", the situation prevailing is that Post Office Counters
Ltd. (P.O.C.L.) give an undertaking that they will appoint a new manager
to operate at the existing premises. In return for this security of
location, P.O.C. now charge a "Franchise Exchange Fee" in respect of
businesses with remuneration exceeding a certain level. The formula
is complex, taking into account the volume and scope of the services
offered by the office in question but applicants should expect offices
with remuneration exceeding £10,000 to most likely be subject to the
franchise fee which is currently 25% of the first year's remuneration
- by deduction at source.
Some
express the view of the 'price' being high but if one considers that
P.O.C.L. (in giving the security of tenure now enjoyed) surrendered
control, to a degree, of its network and has to maintain a significant
establishment of qualified staff & inspectors to train and monitor the
newly appointed - and then may find the business is sold again perhaps
2 years hence - then the level of the charge is better understood.
You
will have noticed the word remuneration and not salary is the correct
term - the latter being a misnomer as the sub P.O. manager is self employed
and is, in effect, an agent for P.O.C.L, not an employee. The remuneration
might be more correctly described as Gross Profit (with which it is
linked in the accounts of P.O.'s which sell goods as well as P.O. services).
It
must also be accepted that it is the norm for those selling sub P.O.
businesses to equate remuneration with Goodwill - as they more likely
that not bought (to a greater or lesser degree) on that basis. Designating
remuneration as Gross Profit makes sense as it has to cover virtually
all the expenses of running the business - not just the operator's salary.
It is not unusual to see Goodwill equated with 2 x annual remuneration
or thereabouts and there is a degree of logic in this assumption as
P.O.C.L. can pay a maximum of 26 months remuneration as a "discretionary
allowance" if they have to/wish to shut down sub P.O.
Do
note that when the remuneration goes above £ 35,000 it becomes increasingly
difficult to operate efficiently without having to pay staff salaries
out of the Post Office "salary". Those running sub P.O.'s will of course
have the facility to charge an element of living costs to the business
and, happily, P.O.C.L. pick up the phone bill and make a substantial
contribution to the cost of holiday relief staff.
The
appointment of Sub-Post Masters/Mistresses is subject to interview and
applicants are expected to be articulate, numerate and adequately funded.
The situation can vary somewhat Region to Region but there can be an
insistence that applicants will only be granted an interview if the
have exchanged contracts subject to contract as regards purchasing (or
otherwise securing) the Office premises.
This
might seem unreasonable until one appreciates that P.O.C.L. cannot appoint
someone to run an element of its business unless it is assured the appointed
person will have premises from which to operate! Consider a situation
where the sale of the premises was all agreed but contracts not exchanged
i.e. no legal commitment made to complete the sale. Our applicant might
have emerged happily from a successful interview only to an unscrupulous
vendor deciding that he might extract a higher price from someone who
now has a job but has yet to secure somewhere to do it! - a highly unlikely
occurrence presumably but who knows.
Some
applicants have expressed misgivings having seen sub P.O.'s being established
in supermarkets. It is our view that the catchment of Offices having
paid the Franchise Fee is contractually secure but P.O.C.L. will expand
in this way where possible is because such outlets for their business
are 'customer orientated' i.e. their, much longer in total, opening
hours are arranged for the convenience of customers, whereas, some currently
running sub P.O.'s may, however, have come into the business for the
very reason that their minimum hours still allow half day (Wed & Sat)
and Sunday closing - and why not. However P.O.C.L. must make the most
of all it's potential areas of operation as, contrary to common belief,
it has no monopoly. Over 95% of Post Office transactions represent work
done on behalf of others e.g. it handles the counter services for Royal
Mail (a totally separate organisation), makes Social Security payments
on behalf of Government etc. and like most agents (including Business
Agents!) if the service is poor the client will go elsewhere so the
message must be that P.O.C.L. are looking for applicants who look as
if they will make the most of the opportunity presented.
It
may well be, of course, that one is considering a business where the
Post Office remuneration is below £ 10,000 p.a. and is linked with a
general store or newsagent - each element supporting the other and,
generally, providing a stable living - and in such instance - no Franchise
Fee payable to 'get at it'.
Sub
P.O.'s designated 'Community Offices' are deemed to have little prospect
of expanding services and in such circumstances P.O.C.L. base the remuneration
on a very limited number of hours of P.O. opening within a shop that
makes very little out of it but keeps it on as a service to customers.
This
short paper is intended to give those contemplating acquiring a sub
P.O. a better understanding of what is involved and should not be seen
as definitive (P.O.C.L. approved) document. If it doesn't answer specific
questions arising, or prompts additional questions, do ask - if we don't
have the answer we will get it or 'point you in the right direction'.
|